|
Debating Styles Australasian style British Parliamentary style Prime Minister The topic of the debate will be framed as a policy motion put to the parliament, usually starting with the phrase, "This House would..." or, "This House believes..." and the Government teams must argue in favour and the opposition teams against. The backbench teams cannot contradict their corresponding frontbench teams but they must differentiate their cases enough to distinguish themselves from their frontbench teams. This usually involves what is termed an 'extension' which simply means analysing the topic from a different angle to the frontbench or concentrating more deeply on a particular facet of the topic. This style of debating is obviously more complicated and nuanced than the Australasian style, and takes more time to master, but it can be very rewarding once you get the hang of it. The mechanics of the competition are basically the same as those for the first semester competition. Debating Tournaments The last and most prestigious tournament of the year is the World University Debating Championships or 'Worlds', which is held over the week of New Year's. At the most recent Worlds at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver, Canada, UQ made it all the way to the finals. We hope to do just as well, if not better, at the 2008 Worlds to be held at Assumption University, Thailand. Also in the UQDS competition calendar is the Women's tournament, the premier women-only debating competition in Australia. UQDS members are strongly encouraged to attend these tournaments as they are great opportunities not only to compete for UQ but to hone their debating skills and meet other accomplished debaters. The society has also taken a leading role in developing debating at a Queensland level. The UQDS, along with the Griffith University and Bond University debating societies, began the Queensland Cup tournament in 2005 to promote debating among Queensland university students. In 2004, we hosted our first Schools Day competition, during which high school debating teams from around Brisbane spend a day at UQ's St Lucia campus competing against each other. This tournament was designed as a fun way to encourage students to develop their reasoning and argumentative skills and to consider continuing debating as they enter university. To find out more about
debating, tournaments and other debating societies, check out our Links
page. Resources Simon Quinn's book gives quite a good overview of important techniques in debating. The Monash Association forum is a pretty impressive forum where the debaters discuss pretty much every single topic known to debating. It also has many links to good newspaper articles. The UQDS live journal has a summary of every debate we do each week. The Debatabase website can also be another useful source (though a little bit basic) for solid debating techniques. Simon Quinn's guide
to debating: Monash Association
of Debaters debating forum: UQDS live journal: Debatabase: |